Thursday, March 23, 2023
Change Oracle Logo
  • Climate Change
    • Greenhouse Gas Emissions
    • Biodiversity
    • Wildfires
    • Extreme Weather
  • Energy
    • Renewables
    • Nuclear Power
    • Fossil Fuels
  • Politics
    • American Politics
    • Canadian Politics
    • International Politics
  • Social Change
    • Activism
    • Disinformation
    • Education
    • Psychology
    • Gender Equality
  • Business and Economics
    • Leadership
    • Decarbonization
    • Economics
    • Supply Chains
    • Investing
  • Technology
    • Carbon Removal
    • Carbon Capture
    • Transportation
    • Buildings
    • Food
No Result
View All Result
  • Climate Change
    • Greenhouse Gas Emissions
    • Biodiversity
    • Wildfires
    • Extreme Weather
  • Energy
    • Renewables
    • Nuclear Power
    • Fossil Fuels
  • Politics
    • American Politics
    • Canadian Politics
    • International Politics
  • Social Change
    • Activism
    • Disinformation
    • Education
    • Psychology
    • Gender Equality
  • Business and Economics
    • Leadership
    • Decarbonization
    • Economics
    • Supply Chains
    • Investing
  • Technology
    • Carbon Removal
    • Carbon Capture
    • Transportation
    • Buildings
    • Food
No Result
View All Result
Change Oracle Logo
No Result
View All Result
Home Other

The Perils of Growth and the Ubiquity of Growthism

by Richard Matthews
April 19, 2018
in Other
0

“To hasten growth is to hasten decay.”
– Lao Tzu

Our growth focused economic models are destroying the earth’s natural systems. When we factor environmental and social considerations our fixation with growth is revealed to be a road to ruin. This is evident from hotter temperatures, rising sea levels, extreme weather, melting ice, collapsing fisheries, water scarcity, expanding deserts, forest fires, dying coral reefs, and species extinctions.

Our conceptions of growth are supported by the idea that we base our decisions on rational assessments that maximize utility as a consumer and economic profit as a producer.  It is becoming increasingly obvious that there are some critical variables being omitted from our assessments.  Ecological degradation, resource scarcity, recessions, and rising rates of inequality make the case that there is something seriously wrong with this economic model.

Common sense dictates that we must factor the earth’s carrying capacity and the planetary boundaries that make up the biological limits of our biosphere. However, our current economic models have failed to incorporate such an analysis. The prevailing ethic is grow or die may be more accurately restated as grow and die.

For decades researchers have been compiling evidence that reveals the dangers associated with our reliance on growth. A 1972 book titled Limits to Growth, predicted the collapse of civilization within a century. The book was premised on an MIT computer model called World3 that predicted if we continue with business as usual the world would succumb to “overshoot and collapse” before 2070. Using UN, NOAA, BP and other statistics Dr Graham Turner from the University of Melbourne corroborated the conclusion of the book. He concluded that his observations are consistent with the World3 predictions.

In the book The End of Growth, Richard Heindberg concludes that “economic growth as we have known it is over and done with.” The book Prosperity Without Growth by Tim Jackson explores the unsustainability of current rates of consumption drilling down on the false dichotomy between environmental action and economic growth.

In an article called The Myth of Progress, American journalist, author, Presbyterian minister, and Princeton University lecturer Christopher Hedges says we are moving in a perilous direction. “The industrial elites are the forces that now doom us. The mania for ceaseless economic expansion and exploitation has become a curse, a death sentence,” Hedges said. “We have bound ourselves to a doomsday machine that grinds forward…We have failed to control human numbers. They have tripled in my lifetime. And the problem is made much worse by the widening gap between rich and poor, the upward concentration of wealth, which ensures there can never be enough to go around.”

The negative consequences associated with the emphasis on growth has been called “growthism”. According to Erik Lindberg Growthism is inexorably embedded in our systems, directing and controlling them, and giving the impression of an inescapable natural law.

Growthism is a belief forged over the last two centuries that subscribes to the dogma that the achievements of our society are principally measured by an increase in economic measures such as GDP and per capita or volume of trade. This view is premised on unquestioned assumptions. The facts indicate that growthism runs counter to humanity’s need to live within the thermodynamic and biological limits of our environment.

Growthism is diminishing our quality of life and threatening life on the planet. According to Erik Lindberg, “our modern framework, with its Growthist Self leading the charge, is responsible for the destruction of the world’s biosphere and is bringing on what scientists refer to as the 6th Great Extinction.” In addition to eco-ruin, growthism feeds a global oligopoly, debt, corruption, class conflict, poverty, and homelessness.

Growthists are ubiquitous and as Lindberg points out, “Every American hero from Christopher Columbus to the present has been a Growthist; and this has not of course changed with the entrepreneurial hero.”  This perspective is shared by both ends of the political spectrum. Although they may differ on how to get there, both liberals and conservatives subscribe to economic models predicated on growth.

The almost universal reliance on growth has serious consequences, because as Kent Welton indicates, “Growthism lacks both context and assent by the vast majority. As such, it is doomed to produce social and ecological ruin and political turmoil.”

Growthism is disconnected from the real world. The values assigned by those who subscribe to growthism are devoid of relation to natural process. The corporate world’s single-minded focus on profits is driving this state of unbalance. As corporate profits have increased we have seen declines in real wages. This is “trickle-up” economics which transfers wealth from the many to the few.

We are living in an age of Growthmania which Paul Ehrlich describes as, “the most pervasive social disease in America… most economists are hooked on growth the way junkies are hooked on heroin.” The growthist model means by definition that there will be losers, lots of them. It is a race to the finish line and the spoils go to the select few. This is an unsustainable system.

Far from addressing this problem, we seem to be doubling down on this doomed economic system. As reviewed in a paper by Herman Daly, Donald Trump is also a growthist.

Related
The Illusion of Growth and the Fallacy of Kuznets Curve

ShareTweetShare
Previous Post

Event – 2018 Shared Value Leadership Summit

Next Post

Event – 2018 Texas Corporate Responsibility Summit

Related Posts

Seasons Greetings from the Green Market Oracle

by Richard Matthews
December 24, 2021
0

American Courts are Defending Democracy and the Environment

by Richard Matthews
December 14, 2020
0

Despite unprecedented challenges, America's legal system has held. In recent weeks the courts have repeatedly defended democracy and in the last four years they have overturned a wide range of environmental...

Environmental Plebiscites: Municipal Referendums and State Ballot Initiatives

by Richard Matthews
November 12, 2020
0

The November 3rd election not only elected an environmentally responsible president it also gave Americans a chance to vote on environmental issues in five state ballots and two city referendums. Americans ...

Next Post

Event - 2018 Texas Corporate Responsibility Summit

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Follow Us

  • Facebook
  • Twitter
  • Email
  • LinkedIn
  • Reddit
  • SoundCloud

Subscribe to the Blog

Enter your email address to subscribe to this blog and receive notifications of new posts by email.

Economics

Ecological Governance Respecting Planetary Boundaries through Degrowth and Social Processes

by Richard Matthews
March 6, 2023
0

Planetary Boundaries We are in need of governance solutions to ecological crises that respect Planetary Boundaries. By re-embedding the economy...

Read more

Precipice: What Will It Take for Us to Avert the End of Civilization

February 27, 2023
Ecological Economics Vs. Classical Economics

Ecological Economics Vs. Classical Economics

February 11, 2023

Renewable Energy is Growing Rapidly but is it Enough to Stop Climate Change?

January 31, 2023
change oracle will explore the fundamental unworkability of capitalism

Confessions of a former capitalist: The journey that made me an advocate of systemic change

January 11, 2023
  • About
  • Climate Change
  • Energy
  • Business and Economics
  • Politics
  • Technology
  • Social Change
  • Events
  • Other

© 2021 Copyright The Green Market Oracle.

No Result
View All Result
  • Business and Economics
    • Leadership
    • Supply Chains
  • Economics
  • Energy
    • Renewables
    • Nuclear Power
    • Fossil Fuels
  • Climate Change
    • Greenhouse Gas Emissions
    • Biodiversity
    • Extreme Weather
    • Wildfires
  • Investing
  • Politics
    • American Politics
    • Canadian Politics
    • International Politics
  • Technology
    • Buildings
    • Carbon Capture
    • Food
    • Transportation
  • Social Change
    • Education
    • Activism
    • Psychology

© 2021 Copyright The Green Market Oracle.

Welcome Back!

Login to your account below

Forgotten Password?

Retrieve your password

Please enter your username or email address to reset your password.

Log In